“Disability Theory is just the book we’ve been waiting for. Clear Tobin Siebers persuasively argues that disability studies transfigures basic. Disability Theory, Tobin Siebers (Ann Arbor: U of Michigan P, pages). Reviewed by Cynthia Lewiecki-Wilson, Miami University of Ohio. Tobin Siebers’. “Disability Theoryis just the book we’ve been waiting for. Tobin Siebers in some of the major debates of the last thirty years in critical and cultural theory.
|Published (Last):||28 May 2006|
|PDF File Size:||18.30 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.13 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
His concern is not simply for a more disabiliity meaning of disability but an awareness that unless we have an inclusive definition of disability, it will continue to be seen as a sign of weakness, pathos, or injury instead of a condition that impacts all of us.
Discourses of Disability Illustration: As for social construction, Siebers recognizes that although experience is constructed through social attitudes and prejudices, the identities produced within such conditions are “real” and valid for purposes of public policy, community formation, and jurisprudence.
Siebers addresses the questions of how disability theory and other forms of critical theory can challenge and inform one another, how disability theory can move past the poststructuralist position that all experience is simply a linguistic construct and give voice to the disabilit experience of disability, thoery how identity politics can move the disability rights movement forward in its struggle for universal access.
Authors Instructors Media Booksellers Librarians. Tobin Siebers is V. In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content: But because he is a superb reader of texts court cases, avant garde art, newspaper and media reports, literary history he can bring much needed local detail to these theoretical arcanae.
The latter are a few of the examples that Siebers uses to show the complex nature of disability and the inadequacy of a one-size-fits-all definition of the term.
Tobin Siebers persuasively argues that disability studies transfigures basic assumptions about identity, ideology, language, politics, social oppression, and the body.
Disability Theory – Tobin Siebers – Google Books
Tobin Siebers is V. It is important not only for its often provocative explorations of such pressing issues as pain, sexuality, and human rights, but also because Siebers is a major participant in one of the most vigorous debates within the field at the present time—the question of methodology and how we do Disability Studies in the humanities. Welcome disabiliyy my blog! The victim becomes responsible for the violence that someone else perpetrates.
It will also broaden the meaning of “access” to include accessibility to spaces and persons, sites of pleasure and erotic practices that are seldom included in discussions of universal design. Siebers’ diagnosis of the close connection between narcissism and disability politics is one of the best aspects of this book and helps explain why disability continues to be a siebegs element in social justice.
Intelligent, provocative, and challenging, Disability Theory revolutionizes the terrain of theory by providing indisputable evidence of the value and utility that a disability studies perspective can bring to key critical and cultural questions. Changing the Conversation Autism and Empathy: In sum, people in wheelchairs, people with diminished sight and hearing, those with difficulty climbing stairs, people uncomfortable reaching high or bending low, and those unable to grasp objects do not fit easily in my house.
Clear, cogent, compelling analyses of the tension between the ‘social model’ of disability and the material details of impairment; of identity politics and unstable identities; of capability rights and human interdependence; of disability and He makes good use of Eve Sedgewick’s Epistemology of the Closet to show the multi-valent meaning of “coming-out” or becoming visible as a disabled person in which the ability to pass is complicated by the phenomenon of invisible disabilities deafness, chronic illness, certain cognitive and neurological impairments, etc.
All human beings must cooperate in such activities as buying and selling goods, constructing buildings, growing food, and raising children. He is highly critical of adapting the identitarian position that reduces all persons with disabilities to a single class, but he also feels that without some sense of collective identity, claiming rights under federal and state protections will be difficult.
Perhaps his most powerful critique is reserved for the accusation of narcissism leveled against disabled persons whose “special needs” require business owners to bend over backwards to accommodate access that able bodied persons take for granted. As a professor specializing in disability studies in the departments of Arts and Design and English Language and Literature at the University of Michigan, Siebers concerns himself, first and foremost, with the question of why disabled people are oppressed in our culture.
This position offers Siebers a chance to attend to complex embodiment in specific cases Deaf persons differ fundamentally from people in wheelchairs in their attitudes about disability; people with chronic illness differ from people with spinal injuries, etc. Disability Theory ‘s cover features a painting Pattern by Riva Lehrer in which the artist depicts herself lying on the grass, drawing with a lipstick an togin outline of a naked woman’s body over her dress while looking at her face in a mirror.
What’s Wrong with This Picture? An Unholy Crusade Person-first language: How do we overturn the medicalized representation of disability that portrays impairment as a purely individual matter of physical functioning? This is a book with a clear agenda: These are social facts readable in the blueprint of my house.
Disability Theory Tobin Siebers No preview available – Clear, cogent, tobih analyses of thekry tension between the ‘social model’ of disability and the material details of impairment; of identity politics and unstable identities; of capability rights and human interdependence; of disability and law, disability as masquerade, disability and sexuality, disability and democracythey’re all here, in dksability crafted and intellectually startling essays.
Therefore, when people with disabilities attempt to communicate their pain, advocate for assistance, or struggle against their oppression, they face the charge of being not only hopelessly trapped in their self-absorbed individuality, siebeers also fully responsible for the responses that ensue Siebers At the same time, he advances the emerging field of disability studies by putting its core issues into contact with signal thinkers in cultural studies, literary theory, queer theory, gender studies, and critical race theory.
I welcome your comments and insights. He understands that as a class that is potentially inclusive of all individuals, claiming disability as a minority position is a hard sell, but he wants to argue for a “complex embodiment” that acknowledges the differences among persons with disabilities.
After all, if disability is not a part of shared humanity, then it places human beings with disabilities outside of the collective of humanity. Keywords disability and minority identity, politics of disability, complex embodiment, disability studies, sexuality, gender, disability, disability theory, identity politics and disability. I can attest to the power of this way of approaching constructed spaces. Because the mirror into which she looks is turned away from us, the artist sees something different from what we, as viewers, see.
Noble intent but to what effect? What we do see is the complex act of self-mirroring that occurs between the natural body the artist is lying sur l’herbe after all through its multiple manifestations as subject and object, woman as siebrrs and woman disabilkty object of gaze, and, finally, disabled subject as creator of her own view of herself.
Siebers’ book is a caution about how easily academic discourse produces the illness it seeks to cure.
Disability Theory Tobin Siebers Limited preview –