Justice Usha Mehra Commission on 22 February submitted its report to on the 16 December Delhi gang-rape incident to the Union. held on were noted and approved by the Commission. Agenda Item No Recommendations of Justice Usha Mehra. Committee Report regarding. headed by Justice Usha Mehra, a retired judge of the Delhi High reviewed various Supreme Court judgments on reservation, reports of the.

Author: Gardara Zukinos
Country: Samoa
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Medical
Published (Last): 24 August 2011
Pages: 416
PDF File Size: 6.91 Mb
ePub File Size: 15.65 Mb
ISBN: 900-5-89173-745-7
Downloads: 76240
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Fenrikora

It is not clear and it is very ambiguous and bereft of necessary details.


The Home Ministry is likely to reject Law Commission’s recommendation for abolition of death penalty, maintaining that time was not ripe yet to mehda it.

Honestely Speaking, Justice Usha Mehra commission report is fallacious, beyond the scope of the justixe, misleading and defective based on insufficient data and inadequate samples and erroneous conclusions drawn based on the selective representations presented by the MRPS deliberately to prove the Commission’s predetermined intention to sub-classify the Scheduled castes, which cannot be relied upon and deserves to be ignored, and rejected in the larger interests of the scheduled castes and in the national intrests as a whole.

The observations of uhsa Commission relating to Scheduled Caste in Andhra Pradesh are not correct and made with an ulterior motive. Further, in Andhra Pradesh, the State is divided into six zones. Law report recommending abolition of death penalty sent to all states: Thus, the observations particularly made with reference to Malas, that for Malas, Madigas are untouchables has no basis and irrelevant and biased and motivated.

The government has created over 1, additional posts in Delhi Police and converted co,mission into the posts of women constable justiice the recommendation of Justice Usha Mehra Commission’s report suggesting one third of the force should be reserved for females. CSR Compendium Touching lives of many. The Commission failed to take note of Articleof the Constitution of India and the judgement of E.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

But, in contrast, the Commission observed that the Adi-Andhras have concered more benefits limiting their population to just 1. Hence the report mehrs the Commission is unilateral, irrational and unreasonable. ET EnergyWorld A one stop platform that caters to the pulse of the pulsating energy. National Entrepreneurship Awards Thus it is prejudicial, pre-determined, pre- judged and the recommendation for sub classification of Scheduled Castes is a foregone conclusion.

While working out the proportionality on the basis of the population, the conclusions of the commissiob are crucial. Justice usha mehra Commission is not a Statutory Commission appointed under any Law. Law panel’s report on death penalty reaches Home Ministry for final call 23 Sep, While dealing with Malas, they were also referred to Adi-andhras.


There are no reservations provided for the posts of High Courts Judges and Supreme Court Judges and there are also no reservations for the post of Ministers and Cabinet Ministers.

The women – both officers and constables – will be deployed in each of the capital’s police stations and handle sensitive cases related to the fairer sex. It also includes the political purpose and their representations in Local Bodies, Municipalities, State Legislature and the Parliament. It is a fact that there are still lakhs of SCs children who are not admitted to schools in spite of Sarva Siksha Abhiyan Scheme and there is inadequate enrollment of students at all the levels and when the scholarships are not cimmission utilized commisson any District under any scheme, and the dropout rate of Scheduled Castes students, which is alarming.

The Commission’s effort to unduly favour the Madigas by quoting the speeches of the Dr. Therefore, the representations were mainly from Madiga and its groups only and the Mala groups were denied the opportunity of hearing by the Commission. In respect of Bindla, a satellite not share wells and common burial ground with other communities. Selecting a few and collecting data from insufficient number and through random surveys we cannot expect a fair and jusgice conclusions.

But, the Commission’s approach from inception appears that it had taken up the responsibility to categorise the SCs without proper application of mind and with a prejudice influenced by the political clout at the behest of the Hon’ble Minister for Social Justice justce Empowerment and the Government of Andhra Pradesh which is espousing the cause of MRPS.

Government of India is concerned with the welfare of the SCs as a whole in the entire country. The Commission failed to note and appreciate that if one caste is little advantaged because of their early schooling or on account of the missionaries starting schools in Coastal areas, it should not be a ground to divide the whole SCs.

They relate to identification of Backward classes and social status of an off-spring of an inter-caste married couple and with regard to creamy layer which is not applicable to the SCs. The observations of the Commission that Madiga is not numerically dominant caste is also fallacious for the reasons that the Commission showed their population as Madiga is one caste among the castes.


Justice Usha Mehra panel may give interim report: The Commission report was submitted in a hurried and hasty manner recommending sub-classification as there was a threat of indefinite fast by the MRPS leader giving a dead line and thus only to satisfy the forces and self-interest groups, the report was submitted probably to save the life of leader of MRPS, a leader of one community ignoring the larger interests of 59 castes in Andhra Pradesh and castes in the country which will cause unrest and encourage divisive forces in every State mehhra Union Territory.


They are outside the chaturvarna system and all are untouchables. They are recruited on National level and merit basis through competitive examination. The recommendation of the Commission that the State Legislature based on the recommendations of the Judicial Commission, shall indicate specifically as to what percentage of reservation benefits shall be given to which caste, races or tribes of SCs or part of or group within in any caste, races or tribes thereof based on their population ratio implies that the State should appoint reoprt judicial commission to carryout the same exercise before taking any further actionbased on the report.

The Commission also committed error in selecting a few institutions for sample study and a limited number of Government departments and agencies identified and selected by the Government which is out and out supporting the cause of MRPS.

The issue of Scheduled Commissioj is a National issue and the reservations are intended for constitutional purpose. They suffer from illiteracy, poverty, squalor, hunger and decease.

Hence there is no need or justification to divide the SCs which is not in the interests of the Country as a whole. But, for the purpose of population adi-andhras are shown separately.

It also failed to review the position of about 30, backlog vacancies which are not filled up in the State.

The Commission also failed to note that the judgement of the Indrashaney is not applicable in respect of Scheduled Castes. Thus, the effort of the Commission to say that Scheduled Castes in Andhra Pradesh are heterogeneous is unconstitutional and unsustainable.

Government Two government appointees in the law panel — then ex-offic Hence, the conclusions drawn by the Commission are inaccurate and based on irrelevant and extraneous consideratons. Or whether the reservations are to be appointed commussion on the region etc.

The fact remains that as it was held impermissible under the Constitution and because the State Government succumbing to the pressure tactics of MRPS, particularly when the plenary session of the Congress was being held at Hyderabad, and to get over the nuisance, such a resolution was passed and the Commission was appointed.

In fact the very Commission report dealt with characteristics of scheduled castes through out the country.